Jump to content

Aviator vs rivals performance comparision


rothen

Recommended Posts

Just yesterday I decided to compare how quick the plugin midsize suvs are compared with their equivalent gasoline version, so I analyzed the main tests that C&D and motortrend did (plus an european magazine that did the test of the Q7 e tron and the Q7 diesel on which the etron is based). I did a quick scheme about main performances data that i'm gonna share, I apologize if the results are kind of confusing to read:
 

 

car hp torque 0-60 0-100 1/4m weight roadholding mpg weight distribution magazine:


x5 35i 300hp 300lb 5.8s/5.9s 15.7s 14.5a96 4974lbs 0.79 - 47.5/52.5 C&D
x5 35i 300hp 300lb 6.0s 16.3s 4911lbs 0.81 20/18/24 49/51 motortrend

x5 40i 2020 335hp 330lb 5.0s 4854lbs 0.88 22/20/26 50/50 motortrend
x5 40i 2020 335hp 330lb 4.9s 13.6a101 4872lbs 0.89 - - C&D

x5 40e 308hp 332lb 6.2s 16.2s 14.7a95 5283lbs 0.82 24/23/25 C&D
x5 40e 308hp 332lb 6.2s - 14.6a94 5263 0.81 46/54 - motortrend

xc60 T6 316hp 295lb 6.1 15.7 14.6a97 4322lbs 0.87 - 23/21/27 C&D
xc60 T6 316hp 295lb 5.5 14.1 14.1a100 4281lbs 0.88 22/19/27 C&D
xc60 T6 316hp 295lb 6.6 15.0a90 4297lbs 0.83 55/45 - motortrend

xc60 T8 400hp 472lb 5.1 13.5 13.7a101 4741lbs 0.84 26/28/26 C&D

xc90 T6 316hp 295lb 6.0 15.5 14.6a97 4706lbs 0.84 52.3/47.7 22/20/25 C&D
xc90 T6 316hp 295lb 6.7 15.1a90 4720lbs 0.85 52/48 - motortrend

xc90 T8 400hp 472lb 5.0 13.9a97 5132lbs 0.84 52/48 27/27/28 motortrend
xc90 T8 400hp 472lb 5.3 14.6 14.0a98 5159lbs 0.81 - - C&D

ML550 408hp 443lb 4.9 11.8 13.4a106 5197lbs 0.85 -/15/20 C&D
GLE550e 436hp 479lb 5.2 13.7a101 5522lbs 0.71 - motortrend

cayenne plugin 416hp 435lb 5.4 12.9 13.7a103 5427lbs 0.83 - - C&D
cayenne plugin 416hp 435lb 5.2 13.0 13.8a103 5373lbs 0.91 - - C&D
cayenne gts 420hp 380lb 5.5 13.6 13.9a101 5108lbs 0.95 -/15/21 - motortrend

Q7 etron 373hp 5.8 - - 5530lbs - - - autobild
Q7 TDI 272hp 6.2 - - 4630lbs - - - autobild

aviator 400hp 400lb 5.2* 4897lbs 21/18/26 - - 
aviator plugin 460hp 600lb/620lb 4.3* 5678lbs - - -

 

I put the asterisk on the aviator performance (the plugin could be rated to 620 lbft of torque since the explorer plugin get that number) I aspect to see. Also we know few data about the new lincoln suv.

And here I pointed out the main differences on kurb weight, hp, torque and 0-60 acceleration) between the plugin and the gasoline version:

x5 40e vs 35i  +300lbs  +8hp  +32lb  +0.2 seconds (6.2 vs 6.0) 
xc60  T8 vs T6 +420lbs  +84hp  +177lb -1.1 (5.0 vs 6.1) 
xc90  T8 vs T6 +430lbs  +84hp  +177lb -1.3 (5.2 vs 6.5) 
GLE550e vs ML550 +325lbs +28hp  +36lb  +0.3 (5.2 vs 4.9) 
cayenne plugin vs gts +280lbs -4hp  +55lb  -0.2 (5.2 vs 5.4)
q7 etron vs TDI +900lbs +100hp +73lb -0.4 (5.8 vs 6.2)
aviator vs aviator plugin +781lbs +60hp +200/220lb -0.9* (4.3*vs 5.2*)

Notice how the plugin is quicker than the gasoline in almost every suv, I suspect it's due to 2 main reasons:


1) instantaneous torque delivered by electric engine(s)

2) More rear-biased weight distribution of plugin suvs (just think how quick is the porsche 911 compared to rivals with the same hp)


When the advantage on torque is consistent, we see bigger difference, like on the volvo and the audi. The cayenne is anomalous here, being quicker and less powerful than the GTS at the same time. So I guess that, considering the monster torque of the aviator, we should see a low 4s number on the 0-60 acceleration. That couldn't look very impressive today, since we have compact performances suvs like the stelvio quadrifoglio that can do a 3.2 seconds 0-60 mph, but just 5 years ago, the aviator plugin could have tied the macan turbo (that used to do 4.2/4.3 seconds on the 0-60 mph) as the quickest suv in the world. 

 

Edited by rothen
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...